Saturday, March 9, 2013

Friendship is Magic: The Cycle of Character Growth


I’ve been thinking a lot lately…..well….I’m always thinking, but I’ve been doing a special kind of thinking, with regards to My Little Pony Friendship is Magic. And this time I thought I would share my thoughts, as I found them very intriguing. I was thinking about the characters of this beautiful show, and their differences in each Season, and why that was, and then I got to thinking about the friendship reports, and how they related to the characters, and how they differed from Season to Season. Let’s take a moment to talk about the friendship reports actually, while on the subject.

The friendship reports are a huge staple of the series, and my personal favorite part of the show. These came at the end of every episode, displaying a moral or message that was (usually) the central theme of the story that had just been told. They tend to involve the main character in some way, and tend to have some sort of lesson that they learn, but…..has it always been like that? And is it still like that? Let us begin by taking a look at the friendship reports from Season 1, to Season 2, to Season 3, look at how they affect the characters, and how they and the characters have changed over the course of the show.



Season 1

In Season 1, we first meet and see the friendship reports at the end of episode 2; Friendship is Magic Part 2: The Elements of Harmony. At the end of the episode, we see Celestia tell Twilight that she can continue living in ponyville with her friends, but that she must continue to study the magic of friendship in her interactions with her friends and ponyville.

This sets the stage for the morals and themes that would go across the Season. Twilight writes each letter, telling Princess Celestia what she’s learned about friendship. The letters are by Twilight only, and focus more on herself and what she’s learned about friendship.

Season 2

In Season 2, the format of the friendship reports changes. At the end of Lesson Zero, the 3rd episode of Season 2, we see all of the mane 6 (except Twilight) go to Celestia and say how sorry they were for not being considerate of Twilight’s feelings. This prompts Celestia to tell Twilight she can turn a friendship report in whenever she wants, and also tells the rest of the mane 6 that they can also send in friendship reports.

This sets the stage for the morals and themes of the Season as well, and separates them from the format of Season 1. For unlike Season 1, now all of the mane characters can write and send a friendship report, even Spike. This causes us to get to see more of the other characters’ stories, and learn more about them and really see what makes them tick.

Season 3

In Season 3, the friendship reports format doesn’t change from Season 2 at all, however, if you watch the 2 Seasons side by side, you will notice a distinct difference in the friendship reports, which is that; Season 3 has practically no friendship reports. Of all 13 episodes in Season 3, only 2 had friendship reports, all the others had none.

One could argue a reason for this might be that the morals are simply told through means other than a friendship report, but I think there may be a deeper underlying theme here….

The Theory

With that in mind, let’s now move on to the theory I present about the themes of each season. Let’s see how the morals are told in each season, and how that affects the morals and characters and their development.

Season 1: The Introduction

In Season 1, the morals are all told by Twilight, who has just moved to ponyville, and barely knows her friends. This means that the morals at the end of each episode are not necessarily about a lesson for the characters, they are simply a lesson that teaches us about the characters, without them showing any kind of growth. As an example, let’s look at the morals of the following Season 1 episodes:

Episode 7: Dragonshy:
I am happy to report that the dragon has departed our fair country, and that it was my good friend Fluttershy who convinced him to go. This adventure has taught me to never lose faith in your friends. They can be an amazing source of strength, and can help you overcome even your greatest fears.

Episode 15: Feeling Pinkie Keen:
I am happy to report that I now realize there are wonderful things in this world you just can't explain, but that doesn't necessarily make them any less true. It just means you have to choose to believe in them. And sometimes it takes a friend to show you the way.

Episode 19: A Dog and Pony Show:
Just because somepony is lady-like doesn't make her weak. In fact, by using her wits, a seemingly defenseless pony can be the one who outsmarts and outshines them all.

These are the 3 best examples of a moral that was simply about introduction to the characters, and nothing more. In Dragonshy, we simply learn that despite her being weak Fluttershy is strong and can be counted on, but Fluttershy doesn’t learn anything or go through any sort of growth in the episode, we just learn about her.

In Feeling Pinkie Keen, Twilight learns that just because she doesn’t understand the way her friend works doesn’t mean she should just ignore her unique ways. Pinkie however doesn’t learn anything or grow, in the episode we simply learn about Pinkie’s character, and nothing more.

And in A Dog and Pony show, Rarity, the main character, learns nothing at all, it is an episode about us learning that just because someone acts lady like, they should not be underestimated, we learn about Rarity, and that is all.

There are very few, if any episodes with this theme of introduction in Seasons 2 and 3. This is because in Season 1, it was more about Twilight learning about her friends, and as a result, we have episodes like the above, in which even though the characters are the star of the episode, they don’t learn anything. We simply learn about them, because Season 1 is when we’re introduced to the characters and when we get to know who they really are.

What’s more, there are more episodes in Season 1 than the other 2 seasons in which the main character doesn’t learn anything from the moral. Here again, are some examples:

Episode 10: Swarm of the Century:
I've learned that sometimes the solution to your problems can come from where you least expect it. It's a good idea to stop and listen to your friends' opinions and perspectives... Even when they don't always seem to make sense...

Episode 14: Suited for Success:
This week my very talented friend Rarity learned that if you try to please everypony, you oftentimes end up pleasing nopony, especially yourself. And I learned this: when somepony offers to do you a favor, like making you a beautiful dress, you shouldn't be overly critical of something generously given to you. In other words, you shouldn't look a gift horse in the mouth*giggle*.

Episode 16: Sonic Rainboom:
I learned how important it is to keep your hooves on the ground, and be there for your friends.

In the following episodes, we have a Pinkie episode, in which the moral applied to all the main characters other than Pinkie, a Rainbow Dash episode, in which Rarity was the one to learn a moral, and in Suited for Success, we have a Rarity episode, where her friends seemed to learn more than she did. In Season 1, just because an episode focuses on a character, doesn’t mean that they will be the one who learns and grows. This is in stark contrast to the way Season 2 and 3 do morals, in which every episode has the main character learning something.

This was all done for the simple reason that, in Season 1, the morals and characters were more about introduction, and they weren’t as important to the characters. We are being introduced to them, so we are the ones doing the learning, not them. We are learning about them and friendship from them, while they aren’t learning as much, merely acting as our means to learn. In Season 1, the morals introduce the characters, and the characters stay themselves for the most part, with the morals being more about general friendship.

Season 2: The Growth

“Suddenly seemingly the lessons at the end of every episode threaten the very essence of the ponies in question who would never be the same, can Fluttershy not be shy, it’s in her name?”
                                                                                                -bbctol_sgap_S2 Pt. 2, the lyrics that first inspired me to write this huge theory


After Season 1, comes Season 2, in which the morals are now told by the 7 mane characters, not just Twilight, and where, as a result, we get to dig more into the characters’ personalities and ways, and learn much more about them, and also, we get to see the characters go through the most growth.

Unlike Season 1, where every now and then an episode came in which the main character didn’t grow or learn anything, every single Season 2 episodes has the moral focused around the main character, and has them learning something. In Season 2 each character episode is clearly and completely focused on that character, a shift from Season 1, but for what reason?

To go off of that, let me point out 1 more thing that’s significant about Season 2’s morals and characters. In Season 2, we see the characters confront their greatest flaws.

Season 2 features the episodes in which Fluttershy confronts her shyness directly, as well as the episodes in which Rainbow Dash learns to be humble and not so proud and boastful of herself. They also feature the episodes in which Twilight must learn to stop worrying so much, as well as Pinkie learning to finally start being responsible when the time comes and respecting others boundaries, even if she wants to help them. We also see Spike finally confront and fight his dragon side, and learn to control himself and resist urges of greed.

However, the 2 other mane characters, Rarity and Applejack, don’t confront their greatest flaws and vices in Season 2, as they already began to in Season 1. Of course despite that, the other characters confronting their greatest flaws does still seem to be a theme of Season 2, and one could argue that Season 2 is the season of which we see all the main characters at their worst. This is because Season 2 was the season of growth.

Season 2 was when we first got to see characters other than Twilight learn a lesson. As a result of this, we got to focus on the other characters more, and learn more about what makes them tick. We got to see them on their own, and also, got to see them at their worst. We got to learn more about what troubles them so much and why, and as a result, Season 2 was where they grew the most. After being introduced to them in Season 1, Season 2 sees the characters we now know grow.

Season 3: The Payoff

This brings us to Season 3, which followed after Season 2, the growth, where the friendship reports seemed to begin disappearing. As you might be able to guess by the underlined word above you, Season 3’s theme of morals and characters, going from introduction, to growth, is payoff.

Season 3 is the season in which we see the growth we saw from Season 2 and even 1, and we see the result of those growths, in which the characters succeed in the real world as a result of their maturity. In contrast to Season 2 when we see the characters at their worst, Season 3 is where we see the characters at their best.

In Season 3 we see Rainbow Dash succeed as a result of learning to not go too far from Season 2, we see Fluttershy able to be assertive when the time calls for it, and we see Twilight taking measures to work at her worriness and see her ultimately succeed more than anyone else. We see little to no friendship reports in Season 3 because, a lot of the lessons are ones they already learned, and the stories focus more on the characters doing their best to improve things for themselves and the world, with no new lesson needed.




The Characters

Now that I’ve gone over the theory I have for all 3 seasons, and how they differ and connect, let’s go over the characters, and see how they flow through this 3 part process I’ve detailed. There are 4 mane characters for which my theory works very well, so I shall go over them first;

Twilight Sparkle – Twilight fits this 3 arc theory very well, due to the nature of her episodes throughout the 3 seasons. In Season 1, we see her character, and are introduced to her. We learn she is one who likes studies, and as a result isn’t very social, and has trouble functioning in social environments like Boast Busters and Winter Wrap Up. We also learn she likes Celestia a lot and really wants to please her from A Bird in the Hoof and At the Gala, and that she takes her studies very seriously.

We’re introduced to Twilight in Season 1, but that doesn’t mean we don’t see her grow. We see her learn about friendship and grow as she goes on adventures throughout ponyville, and also grow a bit herself as a person, learning in Boast Busters to be herself around others, and in Winter Wrap Up to know she can find a special talent and way to fit in anywhere in the real world. Interestingly, Season 1 gives off the impression that Twilight’s greatest flaw is her inability to work well in real world and social situations. But then in Season 2, her greatest flaw is shown to be her anxiety and overworryness. I’m not sure why that is, or if perhaps they combine into 1 or something, but inevitably, we don’t see Twilight at her worst until Lesson Zero.

In enters Season 2, in which we see Twilight fall apart, stressed from worry and anxiety, we see her at her craziest. As a result, this is also the Season in which Twilight finds what she must grow the most from in herself. She learns what she needs to work on if she wants to improve, and we do as well.

Then comes Season 3, in which we see the payoff of her growth from Season 2, as well as some more growth. In The Crystal Empire she learns that it’s time to grow up and start thinking of what the best thing for the world is, and not what’s best for her studies or some game or test. And after that we see a lot of payoff in Magic Duel. In Magic Duel, despite being thrown out of ponyville with Celestia gone, Twilight stays level headed, not freaking out, and goes to Zecora, being open to new ways of learning rather than sticking to her own ways and being stubborn. We also have the climax of the episode, in which Twilight wins using her friends, something she’s learned and grown to use in the first 2 Seasons.

We also see some of the payoff in Games Ponies Play, in which we see Twilight trying not to freak out, and using a simple technique to remain calm and cool, and she’s able to not freak out from the episode as a result, which makes her able to help the issue of the episode in a calm rational manner, a wonderful payoff from her falls in Season 2.

And finally, more than ever, what makes Season 3 the season of payoff, is the ending, in which we see the payoff for all of Twilight’s growth throughout the 3 seasons. Now that she’s grown and learned so much and come so far, she is ready to become an alicorn, and rewarded for all her troubles and adventures she’s been through, and it ends her development perfectly.

Rainbow Dash – Next is Rainbow, who also fits this formula very well. Rainbow Dash is introduced to us in the first Season, and only really has one episode to her, though she also had a major role in Griffon the Brush Off and Fall Weather Friends, and maybe even Over a Barrel. But in Season 1, we don’t see too much growth from her character. Heck, in her big episode, Sonic Rainboom, Rainbow didn’t learn anything, because that’s not what the episode was about. It was about showing Rainbow as a strong fast determined yet boastful pony, who when put in situations when she must live up to the high expectations she sets for herself, can break down. It wasn’t about having Rainbow grow, it was about introducing her to us, the viewers, and it succeeded beautifully. We did see Rainbow learn some things in Fall Weather Friends and Over a Barrel though, which consequently Applejack also learned, but the latter wasn’t huge for her character, while the former was, albeit being a little general.

Then comes Season 2, in which, like Twilight, we see Rainbow at her worst. Here is when her boastfulness and confidence goes a little into overdrive, most prominently in The Mysterious Mare Do Well, and even in May the Best Pet Win and Read It and Weep, though in the latter it’s more subtle, in the simple way that Rainbow cares so much about her image, which no doubt gives her much confidence.

Now, let’s forget execution for a moment here, and look purely at the concept of these episodes, as I know many want one of these episode’s head on a stick. All of these episodes didn’t just show Rainbow at her worst, but showed her key growth. She learns that it’s what’s inside that counts in May the Best Pet Win, and again in Read It and Weep, where she learns to be less insecure about her beliefs and ways, which helps her to be less boastful. And in Mare Do Well, we see her learn to stay humble, and not let praise go to her head, and to keep her head on the ground, and remember to focus on what’s really important, as opposed to her own ego.

In a way we see the result of all this growth in Hurricane Fluttershy, a late Season 2 episode, but we don’t see the full payoff at its best until Season 3, with Wonderbolt Academy.

In Wonderbolt Academy, we see Lightning Dust, who I like to think of as, Rainbow Dash before Season 2. Without the growth of Season 2, Lightning is more proud and boastful, and also less considerate of others’ feelings, which leads to her being expelled. This is where we see Rainbow shine more than ever, and her payoff from Season 2, in which she’s more rational than Lightning about others’ feelings, and is sure not to push herself too hard or go too far, as we saw what happened when she did that in May the Best Pet Win.

Rainbow has some other Season 3 moments too, in Sleepless in Ponyville and Games Ponies Play. In these, Rainbow learns not to force her ideals on others, as well as to be nice to Scootaloo when the time calls, and lend her an open wing, if you will. The former is more growth, while the latter may again, be the result of her Season 2 experiences in May the Best Pet Win and Read It and Weep, learning to give those that may not seem great at first a chance, again, payoff.

Fluttershy – Next comes Fluttershy, who also fits this formula very well. Fluttershy had quite a bit of Season 1 episodes, featuring Dragonshy, Stare Master, Green Isn’t Your Color, and A Bird in the Hoof. The key point here is Fluttershy’s very first episode, Dragonshy. In Dragonshy, Fluttershy learns and grows not at all, like Sonic Rainboom, it is merely an introductory episode. In Dragonshy, we simply learn that despite being shy and meek, Fluttershy can still stand up for her friends when the time calls for it. This is an episode where we are being introduced to Fluttershy, and not when we are seeing her grow in any way. The 3 episodes that come after serve to start her growth though. We see her learn not to bite more than she can chew, to be more honest with her friends, and not to jump to assumptions. While these were all nice parts of growth, none were quite big enough to show a huge change in her, that is, until Season 2.

And Season 2 is where we see Fluttershy at her worst. We see her so shy that all the ponies and animals walk all over her, and we see her unable to fly at all from her fear of stage fright and bullying. Again, let’s ignore the execution of her Season 2 episodes and focus on the concept. These episodes were about Fluttershy dealing with her shyness, and learning to be assertive and overcome her stage fright. These were where Fluttershy faces her greatest flaw, and where she grows the most, as we see in Season 3.

In Season 3 Fluttershy has but one episode, but it is enough to show her growth. In Keep Calm and Flutter On, we see Fluttershy at her very best, as she tries to reform Discord, and sticks to her ways through all trouble. She’s able to be assertive without going too far, and we see this most of all in the climax. In the climax, she tells Discord she won’t be his friend anymore, but then simply walks away silently, sticking to her word, but not rubbing it in or saying more, just like her at the end of Putting Your Hoof Down. The result of this growth is that she’s able to drive the point home to Discord without coming off as too soft or too hard, and as a result, Fluttershy is able to reform the great and powerful Discord, despite what everyone else thought. It’s something she only could have done with her growth in Season 2, and shows the payoff of the development she’s been through.

Spike – And finally comes the little baby dragon Spike, who also fits this theory surprisingly well, for someone who was at first a minor character. In Season 1, Spike only has 1 episode, but this isn’t even where we’re introduced to him. For in Season 1, we see Spike in many episodes, and learn about him there. He’s a baby dragon who’s Twilight’s assistant, given to her by Celestia, who has a more laid back sarcastic personality compared to Twilights. We simply see and learn about Spike in this manner through Season 1, learning more of his relationship with Twilight in Owl’s Well That Ends Well, but we do not learn about his greatest weakness until Season 2; his dragon side.

Season 2 is where we learn what Spike’s greatest trial will be, and is also where we see him at his worst. For Season 2 is where we see Spike give in to his dragon temptation, greed, and become a terrible huge monster like dragon that almost destroys all of ponyville. But this is not the only great growth he goes through in Season 2, Spike also goes through his great identity crisis. For, in being the only dragon in ponyville, it’s not hard to think that Spike will have lots of trouble fitting in, and not help but feel left out and alone at times. And Dragon Quest is when Spike fully accepts that, just because he’s a dragon doesn’t mean he stands out, or is any less greater than the ponies he lives with. These are 2 developments crucial to his character that, show Spike at his most lost, and his greediest.

Season 3 is then in many ways the payoff of these growths, and this is most present in the very first Season 3 episode. For in The Crystal Empire Spike stays close with Twilight and the gang, while never coming off as clingy like in Owl or feeling distant like in Dragon Quest. Spike stays by Twilight’s side as a sidekick rather than a #1 assistant, which results in him being a perfect aid to Twilight whenever she needs help, as we see throughout the episode and in its climax.

One might even argue that Just for Sidekicks links in with this. For while Spike deals with Greed yet again and cares about his gems too much, he’s not afraid to let them go when he feels he must, and does not fall as far as he does in Secret of My Excess, perhaps showing he’s learned a bit in controlling his greed. Spike at Your Service is the one episode that seems to not fit in with this, but I will touch on this later. Until then, know that Season 3 has payoff for Spike as we see him growing to better help his friends in ponyville when they need support.

This leaves 3 other main characters, who do not fit this theory as well, but still do in some ways; Pinkie, Rarity, and Applejack.

Pinkie Pie – Let us start with the one who fits the most, Pinkie Pie. The first episode we see staring Pinkie is Griffon the Brush Off, where we see what her bubbly nature can cause problems with, and see her learn a lesson about inaction, though we won’t see her learn for a while afterwards. For in Pinkie’s next 2 episodes; Swarm of the Century and Feeling Pinkie Keen, Pinkie has zero growth. This is because we are learning about Pinkie here, and being introduced to her character. We are learning about her crazy zany ways and how they work in the real world, and how to adapt to them. Next we see Pinkie learn something in Party of One, and even then, the episodes serves more as one to introduce the other side of Pinkie, rather than to have Pinkie grow from a great  flaw of hers.

Regardless of the paranoia Pinkie learns from in Party of One, Season 2 is where we see Pinkie dealing with what she is perhaps worst at; being responsible, respecting other’s spaces and differences, and learning not to jump to conclusions in an energetic manner. Pinkie learns all of these important lessons, in the hopes of now being more grown up and able to be serious and respectful and calm when the time comes.

Season 3 then ends up actually having some pay off for Pinkie. In her episode, Too Many Pinkies Pies, we see her considerate of her friends when she plays in the lake quietly for Rainbow, is open to Fluttershy’s butterfly method to calm her down, and is very considerate of her friends when things go too far, and doesn’t dodge the fact that, what happened was her fault. In the same way that I like to think of Lightning Dust as Season 1 Rainbow, I like to think of the Pinkie clones as Season 1 Pinkie, Pinkie who’s not as considerate of others and can’t take responsibility for her actions. Though it could also just be the clones, and Pinkie still has much to learn as we see in the episode, but it does show some payoff and growth for her character from previous Seasons.

Rarity – Next comes Rarity, who follows the path in some ways, but some not. Season 1 stays with its introduction theme, most present in A Dog and Pony show. For in A Dog and Pony show, we are simply introduced to Rarity’s more clever strong side, that one might not think is there due to her feminine nature, and also Rarity learns nothing, showing this was clearly meant to show her off. Suited for Success is also an episode mostly meant to introduce her. We have a beautiful song to show off her passion for her craft, and get to see the kind of beautiful dresses she makes, as well as get a taste for the world she lives in.

The final Rarity episode, Green Isn’t Your Color, begins her great growth, which we see continued in Season 2. Here we see Rarity faced with the dilemma of choosing between her friends being pleased, or having herself succeeding in status as she’d like to. In the end she learns to be honest to her friends, and we see this theme continued in Sweet and Elite, her big Season 2 episode.

In Sweet and Elite we see Rarity again faced with choosing between her friends and fame, and again, she lies to keep up her good image, showing perhaps her greatest flaw, and what she’ll have to work at the most. In the end she once again is honest, and learns that she must stay true to herself and not try to change, continuing the theme from Green Isn’t Your Color.

But she has another Season 2 episode, Sisterhooves Social, in which we see Rarity’s trouble with her sister, where she learns to be nice to her and give her some time and fun. Some introduction to her family life and growth at the same time, it feels in many ways like one that’s better suited for the season of introduction, but alas!

After that comes Season 3, where um……Rarity has no episode, so……we can’t really have any idea if her growth and development has payed off. It will certainly be something to look forward to in Season 4. Though with Rarity getting some introduction in Season 2 and growth in 1, she certainly doesn’t fit the theory as well as the others, but alas. ^^

Applejack – And last (but certainly not least) comes Applejack. Applejack is the one sore thumb among the 7, in that her entire development can be traced to constant constant growth, with her greatest sign of payoff being…..in Season 2!

Applejack starts off in Applebuck Season, where we not only learn about her, but also see her greatest flaw; her stubbornness. We see her learn to be less stubborn and open to the ideas of others, a key growth that will continue throughout every single one of her episodes. For in Roundup in Season 2 we see her too stubborn to admit her mistakes and go home a non winner, and in Apple Family Reunion in Season 3 we see her too sure of herself that the reunion is about the what rather than the who, which causes loads of trouble. The only time we see any sort of significant payoff for AJ’s character is in Season 2, in The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000.

In Cider, we see her struggling in the competition against the Flim Flam brothers, and we see her friends come to her aid. Instead of staying to doing things her way, she ponders it, and then welcomes the mane 6 to help and be a part of her family, showing she has learned to let others help when it’s needed, a wonderful growth, but again, that happens in Season 2, and not 3. While it doesn’t fit my theory completely, it does if we think of what comes after payoff.

There is one thing that can be concluded from not just Applejack, but the developments of the other characters too. That is the pattern most stories go with for character development, and that the series will likely retain, which is Introduction -> Growth -> Payoff -> Growth -> Payoff.

You are introduced to characters and learn about them, then you see them grow and face that which troubles them the most, then you see them overcome those and succeed as a result of that growth, and then you see that succeeding brings more growth to be had, and that’s what’s happened here.

Now that Twilight is an alicorn she must learn what it’s like to be one and now has to grow even more. Now that Rainbow Dash is in the Wonderbolts Academy she’ll have to learn to live at the academy and learn what being a wonderbolt really means. Now that Fluttershy has reformed Discord she must learn how to keep him reformed and give him freedom, but perhaps not too much, and how to manage others. And now that Spike has learned to accept himself as a resident of ponyville despite being a dragon, we see the result of this when Spike invents his own code to separate him from normal dragons in Spike at Your Service. The payoff that resulted from all of their growth brings more potential to grow, and more problems that must now be dealt with. It’s a never ending cycle of growth and payoff and growth and payoff, which is in a sense, just the way life is, and how you, me, and everyone else grows as we go through life, so it fits beautifully.

Thus concludes my theory and analysis. I hope you enjoyed this write up, and I look forward to thinking and discussing more about the themes and developments of this show and its many wonderful characters. I look forward to doing that as we all continue to grow ourselves, and see what that brings us, until then, have some pictures, and I’ll see you when fate decides to cross our paths again.






P.S. There’s also one other group of main characters I didn’t mention who fit this well. The CMC are introduced in Season 1, and don’t do much growth, as we see in their episodes, and are just there for us to see how they interact. Then in Season 2, we see them actually learning and growing and messing up, they actually fall quite a bit in Ponyville Confidential. Then in Season 3, I’m not sure if we see results of this growth in One Bad Apple, but we do see the CMC finally succeeding in the real world, and gaining a new member, and expanding the CMC to manehatten, payoff for what they’ve been through in past seasons.

No comments:

Post a Comment